Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine type of turbine. The performance of hydraulic turbines is strongly influenced by the characteristics of. Hydraulic turbines difference between impulse and reaction hydraulic turbines. Kaplan turbine has high speed runner than that of pelton turbine.
Difference between francis and kaplan turbine pdf 23. Difference between impulse turbine and reaction turbine. B francis an american engineer who in beginning designed inward. Francis and kaplan turbines notes for civil engineering. On the other hand francis and kaplan turbines are reacti. The francis turbine is a type of water turbine that was developed by james b. This operates in an entirely closed conduit to tailrace. Differences between francis and kaplan turbines mech4study. Wheels and a francis turbine deduce formulae for power and efficiency for turbines. A hill curve depicts the optimum performance of the model.
Kaplan turbine is a reaction type turbine and pelton turbine is an impulse type of turbine. An example of a reaction turbine is the kaplan turbine and francis turbine. Difference between kaplan and francis turbine compare. Introduction to surface water hydrology hydrologic cycle. Pelton turbines can be installed horizontal or vertical. What is the difference between an orifice and a mouth piece. Study of performance characteristics of a kaplan turbine at constant speed. Hydraulic turbines fundamental operating parameters classification impulse turbines pelton turbines reaction turbines radial flow. The invention of kaplan turbine is evolution in the field of hydraulic turbines or we can say that it is the upgrade version of francis turbine. More than 20 years of siapro experience means the accumulation of experience and knowledge that guarantee internationally competitive solutions. The main differences between impulse and reaction turbines are, all hydraulic energy is converted into kinetic energy by a nozzle in the impulse turbine and whereas in reaction turbine only some amount of the available energy is converted into kinetic energy. Both similarities and differences from hydroelectric turbines present day capacity. A pelton wheel is an impulsetype water turbine invented by lester allan pelton in the 1870s. The company established a factory at 121123 main street in san francisco.
The energy available at the inlet of the turbine is only kinetic energy. Pelton wheel is an impulse turbine where static pressure head of water is converted into mechanical energy. Pelton wheel high working head, tangential water flow, low specific speed, low discharge and impulse type of turbine. Tailrace which is a channel carrying water away from the turbine after the water has worked on the turbines. Difference between impulse and reaction turbine with pdf. What is the difference between a pelton wheel and the francis and. Here reaction turbine consists of fixed blades that act as a moving blade and nozzle. Turbine speci c speed concepts the turbine speci c speed is a quantity derived from dimensional analysis. Francis turbine has two cases, in first one simple francis turbine i. What is the difference between a pelton wheel and the.
Francis turbine is an inward flow reaction turbine. Kaplan turbine low working head, axial water flow, high specific speed, very high discharge and reaction type of turbine. Therefore, the value of specific speed of kaplan turbine is higher than that of the pelton turbine. This turbines may attain up to 250mw of power, the efficiency of these turbines is 85% to 92%. Design and analysis of a kaplan turbine runner wheel. Kaplan turbines can operate under a wide range of head conditions, but francis turbine requires relatively higher head conditions. Pumps, turbines and pipe networks moment of momentum revisited types of pumps and turbines and uses pumppipe systems, networks 2. The kaplan turbine runner has 38 blades while francis turbine runner has 1525 blades in general. Kaplan turbine it is an axial flow reaction turbine. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine scribd. The work deals of the paper are the comparison between the efficiencies of.
Kaplan turbine is smaller and compact compared to francis turbine. You will find the heliciel site, a method of minihydropower plant design, complete, allowing the design and performance estimation and dimensional parameters of the propeller or kaplan turbine, from guide vanes to draft tube. Here reaction turbine consists of fixed blades that act as a. Both serve almost the same purpose only names along with slight operating ways and their time of arrival is different. A reaction turbine is a type of turbine in which the working fluid comes to the turbine under great pressure and the energy is extracted by the turbine blades from the working fluid generally water unlike pelton turbine in which all the energy of the working fluid is. The turgo impulse turbine bridges the gap of specific speed between the pelton wheel and francis turbine. Francis turbine kaplan turbine tyson turbine gorlov helical turbine. Turbines are sometimes differentiated on the basis of the type of inlet flow, whether the inlet velocity is in axial direction, radial direction or a combination of both. Introduction two phase flow water, air in pelton turbines is turbulent and unsteady. Pelton turbine propellers francis and kaplan banki. Subsequent developments were made on francis, pelton and kaplan turbines. Francis turbines are the most common water turbine in use today. Solve numerical problems for a pelton wheels and a francis turbine.
Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine. Evolution from francis turbine to kaplan turbine wikipedia. Banki turbine jonval turbine turgo impulse turbine propeller turbine. Following are the differences between pelton wheel, francis and kaplan turbine.
Difference between kaplan and francis turbine kaplan and francis are two types of turbines which were developed by two different engineers. Kaplan turbine its components, working and application. Francis turbine is a mixed hydraulic turbine the inlet velocity has radial and tangential components while the kaplan turbine is an axial hydraulic turbine the inlet velocity has only axial velocity component. Francis turbine diagram, working, parts, advantages. Francis turbine had some limitations which were overcome by kaplan turbine. The operating water head of a francis turbine ranges from 40 to 600m. The runner of the francis turbine is made up of cast iron, cast steel and stainless steel. Kaplan turbine disposition of shaft is only in vertical direction number of vanes france turbine has very large number of blades 16 to 24 kaplan turbine has very small number of blades 3. As the torrent of water dried up for the first time in thousands of years, it revealed a horrific sight. This method of detailed design, is followed by a complete tutorial for the 3d modeling of the turbine blades, and. The pressure energy at the inlet and outlet of the turbine is atmospheric.
The rotation speed rpm is higher than that of the francis turbine. The turbine is always installed above the tailrace and there is no draft tube used. Pdf design and analysis of a kaplan turbine runner wheel. Measure the difference in elevation between the suction and delivery pressure tapings. Open channel flow specific energy and rapid transitions hydraulic jumps slowly varying flow open channel control structures 3. Impulse turbines are designed to operate under certain water properties, they achieve optimum efficiency operating under the conditions of a high head combined with a low quantity water flow impulse turbines consists of curved cups or blades arranged. This type of turbine consists of moving blades and nozzles. M is the mass flow rate in kgs and h is the pressure head difference over the turbine in. What is the differences between pelton turbine and kaplan.
Pumps, turbines, and pipe networks, part 2 ch 11 young. The head h is difference between headwater and tailwater. On the other hand francis and kaplan turbines are reaction turbine where dynamic pressure head of water is converted into mechanical energy. Difference between pelton, francis and kaplan turbines the pelton, francis and kaplan turbines are water turbines that are rotary machines which convert kinetic energy and the potential energy of the water into mechanical energy that rotates the shaft to produce electric energy.
This method may be used on any hydraulic reaction turbine, including francis and, in particular, kaplan turbines. The water at the inlet of the turbine possesses both kinetic energy as well as pressure energy for effective rotation the blades in a hydropower station. Performance characteristics of this turbine are similar to an impulse turbine, and consist of a flat efficiency curve over a wide range of flow and head conditions. Kaplan turbine is a propeller type reaction turbine. Higher fullload efficiency and higher flow capacities of bulb and pit turbines can offer many advantages over vertical kaplan turbines. In axial flow turbines, the water flows through the runner along the direction parallel to the axis of rotation of the runner. The kaplan turbine is an axial flow reaction turbine, which means that the working fluid changes pressure as it moves through the turbine and gives up its energy. According to their construction, working and operating conditions following are the major differences in francis turbine and kaplan turbine. The mechanical efficiency of the pelton wheel decreases faster by wear than francis turbine. It consists of spiral casing, guide mechanism and draft tube of kaplan turbine runner are similar to those of francis turbine. Francis and kaplan both the turbines come under category of reaction turbine i.
While reasonable results for francis and kaplan turbines can be obtained by steady state analysis, that is not possible for pelton turbines. The difference in the operating head can be extra simply controlled in francis turbine than in the pelton wheel turbine. Shape of the runner decides the flow of water through the turbine. A reaction turbine is a type of turbine in which the working fluid comes to the turbine under great pressure and the energy is extracted by the turbine blades from the working fluid generally water.
The pelton wheel turbine is invented by lester allan pelton, an american engineer. Classification of hydraulic turbines rmd 2501 hydraulic turbines are generally classified as impulseturbineimpulse turbine peltonturgoturbinepelton, turgo turbine reaction turbine francis, kaplan and propeller turbine based on flow direction, they are further classified as. For a kaplan turbine, it depicts the model as though it were operating with its optimum 3d bladetogate cam. The shape of the efficiency diagram conforms well to the measurements. It is an inwardflow reaction turbine that combines radial and axial flow concepts francis turbines are the most common water turbine in use today. The water surface in the tailrace is also referred to as tailrace. They operate in a water head from 40 to 600 m to 2,000 ft and are used primarily for electrical power production. Flow regulation is carried out by means of guide vane assembly.
In both the cases hydraulic energy of water gets converted into useful power output. Hydraulic turbineshydraulic turbines raven mechanical. Hindipelton vs francis vs kaplan turbine comparision. Flow regulation is done by means of a needle valve fitted into the nozzle. Kaplan turbine works on the principle of axial flow reaction. Kaplan turbine is employed, where a large quantity of water is available. As discussed above, it is a type of reaction turbine. In a hydro power plant as outlined in the figure, the difference between the level of. Difference between pelton, francis and kaplan turbines.
Hydraulic turbines and hydroelectric power plants 1. The pelton wheel or pelton wheel turbine is a tangential flow impulse turbine used for high heads of water. The inward flow reaction turbine having radial discharge at outlet is known as francis turbine, after the name of j. Difference between frances turbine and kaplan turbine free download as pdf file. The objective of this manual is to familiarize the students with practical skills, measurement techniques and. Depending on their water supply, hydropower power plants can choose between two categories of water turbines, an impulse or a reaction turbine. To determine the characteristic curves of peloton wheel under constant. A kaplan turbine is a water turbine that was developed by austrian professor viktor kaplan in 19 and francis turbine was developed by james. Kaplan turbine has lesser friction loss and higher efficiency. It is the vertical difference between headrace and tailrace. The difference between a pelton unit and a turgo is that. An example of a reaction turbine is francis, kaplan turbine. Currently, projects with outputs of up to 75,000 kw are being developed. The ratio of utmost and least operating head can even be two in the case of francis turbine.
1221 774 75 971 5 1429 1393 967 736 200 725 758 319 1214 736 738 708 1481 1142 24 263 1169 1210 229 1237 1437 681 1287 890